---
title: Placental Pathology in Birth Injury Claims | Curi Advisory
description: When adverse obstetrical outcomes occur, the placenta may provide crucial answers about causation, timing, and defensibility.
image: https://blog.curi.com/hubfs/GettyImages-2210548589.jpg
---

[Skip to content](https://blog.curi.com/placental-pathology-obstetrical-malpractice-defense#main-content)

[![Curi](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Curi-logo-horizontal-positive-2.png?width=1443&height=479&name=Curi-logo-horizontal-positive-2.png "Curi")](https://curi.com/)

Mobile Menu Icon

- [Home](https://blog.curi.com)
- [Request Topic](https://share.hsforms.com/1a9ssFAKcTDWA-LBmRgaeowcuu4r)
- Topics
  
  Show submenu for Topics 
  
    - [Claims](https://blog.curi.com/tag/claims)
    - [Clinical Care](https://blog.curi.com/tag/clinical-care)
    - [Health Policy](https://blog.curi.com/tag/health-policy)
    - [Litigation Education](https://blog.curi.com/tag/litigation-education)
    - [Market Commentary](https://blog.curi.com/tag/market-commentary)
    - [MPL Insurance](https://blog.curi.com/tag/mpl-insurance)
    - [Practice Management](https://blog.curi.com/tag/practice-management)
    - [Risk Management](https://blog.curi.com/tag/risk-management)
    - [Wealth Management](https://blog.curi.com/tag/wealth-management)
    - [Well-Being](https://blog.curi.com/tag/well-being)
- [Subscribe](https://share.hsforms.com/1couqp4WFRrS7xtWs6x0y-Qcuu4r)

- [Home](https://blog.curi.com)
- [Request Topic](https://share.hsforms.com/1a9ssFAKcTDWA-LBmRgaeowcuu4r)
- Topics
  
  Show submenu for Topics 
  
    - [Claims](https://blog.curi.com/tag/claims)
    - [Clinical Care](https://blog.curi.com/tag/clinical-care)
    - [Health Policy](https://blog.curi.com/tag/health-policy)
    - [Litigation Education](https://blog.curi.com/tag/litigation-education)
    - [Market Commentary](https://blog.curi.com/tag/market-commentary)
    - [MPL Insurance](https://blog.curi.com/tag/mpl-insurance)
    - [Practice Management](https://blog.curi.com/tag/practice-management)
    - [Risk Management](https://blog.curi.com/tag/risk-management)
    - [Wealth Management](https://blog.curi.com/tag/wealth-management)
    - [Well-Being](https://blog.curi.com/tag/well-being)
- [Subscribe](https://share.hsforms.com/1couqp4WFRrS7xtWs6x0y-Qcuu4r)

# The Placenta—Obstetrics' Black Box and a Critical Piece of Evidence: Defending Obstetrical Care

[Margaret Curtin MPA, HCA, DFASHRM, CPHRM, CPCU](https://blog.curi.com/author/margaret-curtin-mpa-hca-dfashrm-cphrm-cpcu)  Nov 19, 2026

[Risk Management](https://blog.curi.com/tag/risk-management)

![Nurse preparing a placenta for pathology submission in a labor and delivery unit ](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/GettyImages-2210548589.jpg?width=960&name=GettyImages-2210548589.jpg)

Often called obstetrics’ “black box,” the placenta may hold key evidence about neonatal injury. Curi Advisory’s Margaret Curtin explores why preservation is paramount.

Over the past two articles in this series, we have explored the importance of preserving the objective data that helps tell the story of a delivery—[electronic fetal monitoring records](https://blog.curi.com/fetal-monitoring-data-retention-obstetrical-malpractice-defense) and [umbilical cord blood gases](https://blog.curi.com/umbilical-cord-blood-gases-why-they-matter-in-ob-claims). This time, we are turning our attention to another critical piece of evidence that deserves equal consideration: the placenta. 

Often referred to as the "black box" of obstetrics, the placenta may provide critical information regarding what happened before labor, during labor, or even weeks before delivery.

Yet during obstetrical clinical assessments, we continue to identify variability regarding when placentas are preserved and sent for pathology review.

From a medical malpractice perspective, discarding the placenta following an adverse neonatal outcome may permanently eliminate one of the most important pieces of evidence available.

## Key Takeaways:

- Placental pathology often provides critical clues about neonatal injury that may not be apparent from the clinical record alone.
- Once a placenta is discarded, the opportunity to objectively evaluate alternative causes of injury may be lost forever.
- Standardized preservation, pathology review, and documentation processes can help strengthen both patient care and defensibility.

## Why Placental Pathology Matters in Birth Injury Cases

One of the reasons we place high importance on placental evaluation is that it may reveal conditions that may otherwise be challenging to identify, such as:

- Chronic placental insufficiency.
- Infection or inflammation.
- Vascular abnormalities.
- Fetal vascular malperfusion.
- Infarction.
- Thrombotic lesions.
- Abruption.
- Congenital infection.

Importantly, many of these conditions may predate labor. In cases involving allegations of birth injury, placental findings may help provide evidence that points to alternative explanations for neonatal injury.

## What Happens When the Placenta Is Discarded: A Claims Example

Consider a scenario we have seen in claims reviews. A newborn initially appears well but develops seizures several hours after birth and is transferred to a tertiary NICU. The placenta is discarded because no standardized preservation process is in place.

Years later, litigation is filed alleging negligent intrapartum management. Defense experts suspect chronic placental disease and fetal vascular malperfusion contributed significantly to the infant's injury. Unfortunately, the placenta no longer exists, and the opportunity to objectively evaluate causation has been lost.

## Cost of Lost Evidence: Birth Injury Settlements, Verdicts, and Defense Costs

In my experience, placental pathology findings frequently identify chronic conditions, infection, vascular abnormalities, or developmental processes that were present before labor. When the placenta is available, we have an opportunity to better understand what happened; once the placenta is discarded, we lose that opportunity.

| **Evidence Status** | **Potential Effect on Claim** |
| --- | --- |
| Placenta available for pathology review | Opportunity to identify alternative or contributing causes of neonatal injury. |
| Placenta discarded | Loss of potentially critical evidence, increased uncertainty regarding causation, and greater defense challenges. |

Discarding the placenta may permanently eliminate critical evidence needed to establish alternative causes of neonatal injury, increasing litigation risk and settlement pressure. If a court determines the evidence was improperly lost or destroyed, it may permit the jury to infer the missing evidence would have been unfavorable to the defense.

Birth injury claims involving permanent neurologic injury, like the claims example above, routinely settle for $1 million or more, with catastrophic cases and jury verdicts frequently ranging from $5 million to more than $30 million. Defense costs alone commonly exceed $100,000 and may reach $300,000 or more in complex litigation.

## Standardizing the Process

Standardization helps to ensure important opportunities aren’t missed during complicated clinical situations—an organization should establish formal criteria identifying when placental pathology is required.

Criteria should include maternal, fetal, neonatal, and gross placental findings, and should be broad enough to capture events involving suspected infection, abruption, fetal growth restriction, preterm birth, non-reassuring fetal testing requiring urgent delivery, severe hypertensive disease, neonatal depression, seizures, suspected encephalopathy, NICU transfer, or other evidence of neurologic compromise.

Examples include:

Maternal Conditions

- Hypertensive disorders.
- Diabetes.
- Maternal fever.
- Suspected infection.
- Placental abruption.
- Trauma.
- Premature rupture of membranes.
- Low APGAR scores.
- Cord pH less than 7.1.
- Category III fetal heart tracing.
- NICU admission.
- Neonatal neurologic abnormalities.
- Seizures.
- Hypotonia.
- Prematurity.
- Stillbirth.
- Placental abnormalities.
- Meconium staining.
- Cord abnormalities.
- Abnormal placental size.
- Suspected placental injury.

Neonatal Conditions

- Low APGAR scores.
- Cord pH less than 7.1.
- Category III fetal heart tracing.
- NICU admission.
- Neonatal neurologic abnormalities.
- Seizures.
- Hypotonia.
- Prematurity.
- Stillbirth.

Placental Conditions

- Placental abnormalities.
- Meconium staining.
- Cord abnormalities.
- Abnormal placental size.
- Suspected placental injury.

## Nursing's Role in Placental Pathology Requests

Nurses also play a critical role and serve as an important safety net by automatically initiating placental pathology requests when established criteria are met. This approach can help reduce variability and improve consistency.

# Placenta Labeling, Storage, and Documentation Best Practices

When placental examination is requested, pathology forms should include sufficient maternal, fetal, and neonatal clinical information to assist the pathologist in interpreting findings.

Policies should also specify how placentas are labeled, stored, transferred to pathology, tracked, and retained when litigation or significant adverse outcomes are reasonably foreseeable. I’ve seen cases where incomplete clinical information may limit the usefulness of pathology results.

# Risk Reduction Strategies

We recommend organizations:

- Standardize placental preservation criteria.
- Empower nurses to initiate placental pathology reviews.
- Establish standardized placenta labeling, storage, tracking, and retention processes.
- Strengthen pathology and clinical documentation.

# Bottom Line: Preserve the Placenta, Protect Your Defense

Once discarded, the placenta cannot be recovered. In today's obstetrical malpractice environment, placental pathology may substantially influence both clinical understanding and medicolegal defense. Good medicine deserves a good defense.

# A Proactive Risk Management Opportunity

Curi Advisory’s Risk Consulting Team, powered by ERC Risk, offers Obstetrical Clinical Risk Assessments that evaluate neonatal resuscitation practices, cord blood gas processes, documentation, and interdisciplinary communication to identify opportunities for improvement before an adverse event occurs.

The assessments evaluate high-risk clinical practices, including:

- Electronic fetal monitoring interpretation and competency
- Emergency cesarean delivery response
- Communication and escalation processes
- Documentation practices
- Shoulder dystocia preparedness
- Obstetrical emergency simulation
- Teamwork and culture of safety
- Policies, procedures, and guideline compliance
- Medical malpractice defensibility

We partner with hospitals, health systems, and physician organizations nationwide to identify clinical and operational risks before they result in patient harm or medical malpractice claims. Whether your goal is improving patient outcomes, strengthening your medical malpractice defense, preparing for underwriting review, or reducing organizational risk, our experienced obstetrical risk consultants can help.

Request an Obstetrical Clinical Risk Assessment or contact my team at [risk.consulting@curi.com](mailto:risk.consulting@curi.com) to learn more about an Obstetrical Clinical Risk Assessment. 

##### ``

---

**References**

- [https://www.expertinstitute.com/resources/insights/jury-awards-family-30-55m-for-failure-to-monitor-fetus-heart-rate/](https://www.expertinstitute.com/resources/insights/jury-awards-family-30-55m-for-failure-to-monitor-fetus-heart-rate/)
- [https://www.lubinandmeyer.com/cases/fetal\_heart\_rate.html](https://www.lubinandmeyer.com/cases/fetal_heart_rate.html)
- [https://www.medlawhelp.com/blog/fetal-decelerations-29m/](https://www.medlawhelp.com/blog/fetal-decelerations-29m/)

*The content contained herein was generated by Curi Advisory with the assistance of an AI-based system to augment the effort.*

*These resources and guidance are offered for educational and risk management purposes only. This information is not medical or legal advice, does not replace independent professional judgment, does not constitute an endorsement of any kind, should not be deemed authoritative, and does not establish a standard of care in clinical settings or in courts of law. If you need legal advice, you should consult your independent/corporate counsel. We have found that using risk mitigation efforts can reduce malpractice risk; however, we do not make any guarantees that following these risk recommendations will prevent a complaint, claim, or suit from occurring, or mitigate the outcome(s) associated with any of them.*

SHARE THIS POST

[![Share on facebook](https://7528309.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hub/7528309/hubfs/raw_assets/public/mV0_d-web-default-modules_hubspot/img/facebook-color.png?width=24&name=facebook-color.png)](https://www.facebook.com/share.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.curi.com%2Fplacental-pathology-obstetrical-malpractice-defense%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_source%3Dfacebook) [![Share on linkedin](https://7528302.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hub/7528302/hubfs/raw_assets/public/mV0_d-web-default-modules_hubspot/img/linkedin-color.png?width=24&name=linkedin-color.png)](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.curi.com%2Fplacental-pathology-obstetrical-malpractice-defense%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_source%3Dlinkedin) [![Share on email](https://7528311.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hub/7528311/hubfs/raw_assets/public/mV0_d-web-default-modules_hubspot/img/email-color.png?width=24&name=email-color.png)](mailto:?subject=Check+out+https%3A%2F%2Fblog.curi.com%2Fplacental-pathology-obstetrical-malpractice-defense%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_source%3Demail&body=Check+out+https%3A%2F%2Fblog.curi.com%2Fplacental-pathology-obstetrical-malpractice-defense%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_source%3Demail)

 

### About the Author

![](https://blog.curi.com/hubfs/Margaret%20Curtain.png) 

[Margaret Curtin MPA, HCA, DFASHRM, CPHRM, CPCU](https://blog.curi.com/author/margaret-curtin-mpa-hca-dfashrm-cphrm-cpcu)

 Margaret Curtin joined the Curi Advisory team in 2023, as Program Director for its risk consulting arm offering clinical risk assessments, claim management, practice management and education support services to hospitals, healthcare organizations and physician groups. With over 30 years of experience in risk management and patient safety, Margaret is a well-known leader in the field.

In addition to the medical professional liability insurance industry, she has first-hand healthcare experience, having worked in acute, managed, and ambulatory care settings. Throughout her career, Margaret has also held positions in provider relations, contracting, business development, marketing, education, and underwriting.

She is a published author and frequently speaks at industry events and conferences. Margaret is a certified coach and Five Behaviors Certified Practitioner with Wiley in association with Patrick Lencioni. Focusing her coaching practice on leadership and unlocking the power of teamwork for aspiring professionals in the healthcare and the insurance industries.

This is a search field with an auto-suggest feature attached.

- There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

### Insights In Your Inbox

### Popular posts

[![Litigation Education ](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Litigation%20Education-3.png?width=352&name=Litigation%20Education-3.png)](https://blog.curi.com/litigation-education-legal-terminology-in-litigation)

#### [Litigation Education: Legal Terminology in Litigation](https://blog.curi.com/litigation-education-legal-terminology-in-litigation)

Dec 06, 2024

[![Physician checking a text message about a patient on a smartphone](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/GettyImages-2242235350.jpg?width=352&name=GettyImages-2242235350.jpg)](https://blog.curi.com/blog/texting-patients-malpractice-risk)

#### [When "Just a Quick Text" Becomes Exhibit A: How Provider Texting Habits Shape Malpractice Claims](https://blog.curi.com/blog/texting-patients-malpractice-risk)

Sep 10, 2026

[![Career, Community & Change](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Damian%20blog.jpg?width=352&name=Damian%20blog.jpg)](https://blog.curi.com/career-community-change)

#### [Career, Community & Change](https://blog.curi.com/career-community-change)

Feb 07, 2025

[![Medical Chaperone Sensitive Exam](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/iStock-2206909232.jpg?width=352&name=iStock-2206909232.jpg)](https://blog.curi.com/medical-chaperones-sensitive-exams)

#### [The Importance of Chaperones in Sensitive Medical Exams](https://blog.curi.com/medical-chaperones-sensitive-exams)

Jun 12, 2025

[![Navigating Assurance of Patient Wishes](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/iStock-1200995231.jpg?width=352&name=iStock-1200995231.jpg)](https://blog.curi.com/navigating-family-disagreements-ensuring-patient-wishes-are-honored)

#### [Navigating Family Disagreements: Ensuring Patient Wishes Are Honored](https://blog.curi.com/navigating-family-disagreements-ensuring-patient-wishes-are-honored)

Apr 10, 2025

### Posts by Topic

- [Risk Management (41)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/risk-management)
- [MPL Insurance (37)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/mpl-insurance)
- [Well-Being (34)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/well-being)
- [Practice Management (31)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/practice-management)
- [Wealth Management (27)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/wealth-management)
- [Claims (25)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/claims)
- [Litigation Education (18)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/litigation-education)
- [Clinical Care (9)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/clinical-care)
- [Health Policy (6)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/health-policy)

See all

### Follow Us

[Follow us on Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/LiveCuri) [Follow us on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/company/livecuri)

### Comments

[![CURI\_horizontal\_reverse](https://blog.curi.com/hubfs/CURI_horizontal_reverse.svg "CURI_horizontal_reverse")](https://curi.com/)

700 Spring Forest Road

Suite 400

Raleigh, NC 27609

[800-328-5532](tel:800-328-5532)

# FOLLOW US

[Follow us on Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/LiveCuri/) [Follow us on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/livecuri) [Vimeo](https://vimeo.com/curivideo)

Copyright 2026

- [Advisory](https://curi.com/advisory/)
- [Capital](https://curi.com/capital/)
- [Insurance](https://curi.com/insurance/)
- [Home](https://blog.curi.com/)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Margaret Curtin, MPA, HCA, DFASHRM, CPHRM, CPCU",
    "url" : "https://blog.curi.com/author/margaret-curtin-mpa-hca-dfashrm-cphrm-cpcu"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-19T13:49:31.737Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-11-19T13:49:31.000Z",
  "headline" : "Placental Pathology in Birth Injury Claims | Curi Advisory ",
  "image" : [ "https://blog.curi.com/hubfs/GettyImages-2210548589.jpg" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://blog.curi.com/placental-pathology-obstetrical-malpractice-defense",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://blog.curi.com/hubfs/Curi-logo-horizontal-positive-2.png"
    },
    "name" : "Curi - Raleigh, NC"
  }
}
```