--- title: Could Your Billing Practices Affect Malpractice Verdicts? description: Kristi Wright discusses the ways that your billing practices may impact payouts in cases of plaintiff's verdicts during medical malpractice cases. image: https://blog.curi.com/hubfs/iStock-1406459610.jpg --- [Skip to content](https://blog.curi.com/could-your-billing-practices-affect-malpractice-verdicts#main-content) [![Curi](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Curi-logo-horizontal-positive-2.png?width=1443&height=479&name=Curi-logo-horizontal-positive-2.png "Curi")](https://curi.com/) Mobile Menu Icon - [Home](https://blog.curi.com) - [Request Topic](https://share.hsforms.com/1a9ssFAKcTDWA-LBmRgaeowcuu4r) - Topics Show submenu for Topics - [Claims](https://blog.curi.com/tag/claims) - [Clinical Care](https://blog.curi.com/tag/clinical-care) - [Health Policy](https://blog.curi.com/tag/health-policy) - [Litigation Education](https://blog.curi.com/tag/litigation-education) - [Market Commentary](https://blog.curi.com/tag/market-commentary) - [MPL Insurance](https://blog.curi.com/tag/mpl-insurance) - [Practice Management](https://blog.curi.com/tag/practice-management) - [Risk Management](https://blog.curi.com/tag/risk-management) - [Wealth Management](https://blog.curi.com/tag/wealth-management) - [Well-Being](https://blog.curi.com/tag/well-being) - [Subscribe](https://share.hsforms.com/1couqp4WFRrS7xtWs6x0y-Qcuu4r) - [Home](https://blog.curi.com) - [Request Topic](https://share.hsforms.com/1a9ssFAKcTDWA-LBmRgaeowcuu4r) - Topics Show submenu for Topics - [Claims](https://blog.curi.com/tag/claims) - [Clinical Care](https://blog.curi.com/tag/clinical-care) - [Health Policy](https://blog.curi.com/tag/health-policy) - [Litigation Education](https://blog.curi.com/tag/litigation-education) - [Market Commentary](https://blog.curi.com/tag/market-commentary) - [MPL Insurance](https://blog.curi.com/tag/mpl-insurance) - [Practice Management](https://blog.curi.com/tag/practice-management) - [Risk Management](https://blog.curi.com/tag/risk-management) - [Wealth Management](https://blog.curi.com/tag/wealth-management) - [Well-Being](https://blog.curi.com/tag/well-being) - [Subscribe](https://share.hsforms.com/1couqp4WFRrS7xtWs6x0y-Qcuu4r) # Could Your Billing Practices Affect Malpractice Verdicts? [Kristi Wright MBA, CPCU, AIC](https://blog.curi.com/author/kristi-wright) Aug 03, 2023 [MPL Insurance](https://blog.curi.com/tag/mpl-insurance) ![](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/iStock-1406459610.jpg?width=960&name=iStock-1406459610.jpg) *Kristi Wright discusses the ways that your billing practices may impact payouts in cases of plaintiff's verdicts during medical malpractice cases.* Healthcare prices in the United States have risen significantly over the years, becoming a major source of concern for many Americans. This is nothing new, and doctors and patients alike have felt the effects of this shift. However, something that’s not discussed as often is the effect that billed charges have on jury sentiment, and therefore, malpractice verdicts.   # **What’s the issue?**  Practices understandably want to ensure that they’re optimizing fees received from health insurance companies, but they may not realize that these efforts could also increase the economic damages claimed by plaintiffs against the practice in a malpractice case.   It may be customary to bill at 200–300% of Medicare rates to ensure that a practice recovers the max allowable by health insurers; however, in many states, the billed amounts (not the amounts paid to the practice) are what plaintiffs’ attorneys put in front of a jury as the economic damages claimed. Oftentimes, these states have what’s called the “collateral source” rule, a guideline that generally prohibits the admission of evidence that the plaintiff has received compensation from another source, such as health insurance, to keep the defendant(s) from benefitting from payments made by others. That means that the entire billed amounts are put in front of jurors in those states, even though those amounts are never actually paid to the practice and the majority is written off.  As a result, the evidence reflecting the difference between the dollars billed and paid is often referred to as “phantom damages.”  In one recent case, a practice was charging approximately 500% of Medicare rates, and for some services even more. The total billed for the plaintiff’s treatment was nearly $1M for relatively straight-forward procedures, and the total paid by health insurance was approximately $200,000. Given that the lawsuit was in a collateral source state, the plaintiff was permitted to present evidence of $1M in medical bills to the jury as the damages.. The plaintiff’s attorney used these phantom amounts to argue that the practice was profit-motivated and not acting in the best interest of the patient. Unfortunately, the jury found for the plaintiff and used the amount billed as the basis for their award.  # **What are the rules in my state?**  **Florida**, **Georgia**, **Maryland**, **South Carolina** and **Virginia** all follow the collateral source rule, so billed fees and charges (phantom damages) are presented to the jury as economic damages.   **Delaware** follows the collateral source rule when bills were paid by private insurers; however, if the bills are paid by Medicare or Medicaid only the paid amounts would be considered.  In **New** **Jersey**, a plaintiff cannot collect on medical bills reimbursed by a first party medical insurance carrier. However, ERISA plans, Medicare, and Medicaid are excluded.   **North** **Carolina** claims are subject to evidentiary Rule 414, which limits evidence to prove past medical expenses to evidence of the amounts actually paid, or required to be paid, to satisfy the bill. Under this rule, plaintiffs cannot seek the amount billed for medical expenses where those expenses have been negotiated down by the plaintiff’s health insurer or written off by the provider.   In **Pennsylvania**, medical bills that have been paid by insurance are not recoverable; liens/medical expenses paid by an ERISA health plan or Medicare/Medicaid (DPW) are admissible or recoverable.  # **What can be done?**  Practice leaders should be cognizant that optimizing fee schedules to maximize reimbursement may impact (and increase) damages plaintiffs can allege and recover in medical malpractice actions. Payers are constantly changing payment terms, so considering all relevant factors can be a moving target that deserves regular and periodic monitoring.     ### About the Author ![](https://blog.curi.com/hubfs/Kristi.Wright.resize_150x150.jpg) [Kristi Wright MBA, CPCU, AIC](https://blog.curi.com/author/kristi-wright) Kristi Wright is the Senior Vice President of Claims at Curi Insurance, and has been with the Curi organization for 15 years. Kristi earned a BA in Economics from the University of Virginia and completed her MBA from the University of Illinois. This is a search field with an auto-suggest feature attached. - There are no suggestions because the search field is empty. ### Subscribe to our Blog ### Popular posts [![Litigation Education ](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Litigation%20Education-3.png?width=352&name=Litigation%20Education-3.png)](https://blog.curi.com/litigation-education-legal-terminology-in-litigation) #### [Litigation Education: Legal Terminology in Litigation](https://blog.curi.com/litigation-education-legal-terminology-in-litigation) Dec 06, 2024 [![Career, Community & Change](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Damian%20blog.jpg?width=352&name=Damian%20blog.jpg)](https://blog.curi.com/career-community-change) #### [Career, Community & Change](https://blog.curi.com/career-community-change) Feb 07, 2025 [![Medical Chaperone Sensitive Exam](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/iStock-2206909232.jpg?width=352&name=iStock-2206909232.jpg)](https://blog.curi.com/medical-chaperones-sensitive-exams) #### [The Importance of Chaperones in Sensitive Medical Exams](https://blog.curi.com/medical-chaperones-sensitive-exams) Jun 12, 2025 [![Navigating Assurance of Patient Wishes](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/iStock-1200995231.jpg?width=352&name=iStock-1200995231.jpg)](https://blog.curi.com/navigating-family-disagreements-ensuring-patient-wishes-are-honored) #### [Navigating Family Disagreements: Ensuring Patient Wishes Are Honored](https://blog.curi.com/navigating-family-disagreements-ensuring-patient-wishes-are-honored) Apr 10, 2025 [![litigation series](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/litigation%20series.jpg?width=352&name=litigation%20series.jpg)](https://blog.curi.com/understanding-the-timeline-of-a-medical-malpractice-lawsuit) #### [Litigation Education: Understanding the Timeline of a Medical Malpractice Lawsuit](https://blog.curi.com/understanding-the-timeline-of-a-medical-malpractice-lawsuit) Oct 10, 2024 ### Posts by Topic - [Risk Management (39)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/risk-management) - [MPL Insurance (37)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/mpl-insurance) - [Well-Being (34)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/well-being) - [Practice Management (31)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/practice-management) - [Wealth Management (27)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/wealth-management) - [Claims (25)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/claims) - [Litigation Education (18)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/litigation-education) - [Clinical Care (9)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/clinical-care) - [Health Policy (6)](https://blog.curi.com/tag/health-policy) See all ### Follow Us [Follow us on Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/LiveCuri) [Follow us on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/company/livecuri) [Follow us on Twitter](https://twitter.com/LiveCuri) ### Comments ## You might also like [![](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/iStock-1346156630.jpg?width=352&name=iStock-1346156630.jpg)](https://blog.curi.com/standing-ground-against-a-bully-what-to-do-when-plaintiffs-attorneys-use-scare-tactics-pre-trial) ### [Standing Ground Against a Bully—What to Do When Plaintiff’s Attorneys Use Scare Tactics Pre-Trial](https://blog.curi.com/standing-ground-against-a-bully-what-to-do-when-plaintiffs-attorneys-use-scare-tactics-pre-trial) *Kristi Wright explores various scare tactics used by plaintiff's attorneys and explains how doctors...* [![](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/iStock-1346156748-1.jpg?width=352&name=iStock-1346156748-1.jpg)](https://blog.curi.com/getting-back-to-the-courtroom-to-defend-good-medicine) ### [Getting Back to the Courtroom to Defend Good Medicine](https://blog.curi.com/getting-back-to-the-courtroom-to-defend-good-medicine) In March 2020, much of the world was brought to a standstill as the COVID-19 pandemic sent daily... [![](https://blog.curi.com/hs-fs/hubfs/iStock-2161571509.jpg?width=352&name=iStock-2161571509.jpg)](https://blog.curi.com/what-to-expect-when-youve-been-sued-a-new-curi-educational-initiative) ### [Litigation Education: What to Expect When You’ve Been Sued- A New Curi Educational Initiative](https://blog.curi.com/what-to-expect-when-youve-been-sued-a-new-curi-educational-initiative) In this new blog series kick-off, Kristi Wright previews a new multi-faceted educational program to... [![CURI\_horizontal\_reverse](https://blog.curi.com/hubfs/CURI_horizontal_reverse.svg "CURI_horizontal_reverse")](https://curi.com/) 700 Spring Forest Road Suite 400 Raleigh, NC 27609 [800-328-5532](tel:800-328-5532) # FOLLOW US [Follow us on Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/LiveCuri/) [Follow us on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/livecuri) [Vimeo](https://vimeo.com/curivideo) Copyright 2026 - [Advisory](https://curi.com/advisory/) - [Capital](https://curi.com/capital/) - [Insurance](https://curi.com/insurance/) - [Home](https://blog.curi.com/) ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Kristi Wright, MBA, CPCU, AIC", "url" : "https://blog.curi.com/author/kristi-wright" }, "dateModified" : "2023-10-27T15:40:35.221Z", "datePublished" : "2023-08-03T19:01:04.000Z", "headline" : "Could Your Billing Practices Affect Malpractice Verdicts?", "image" : [ "https://blog.curi.com/hubfs/iStock-1406459610.jpg" ], "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://blog.curi.com/could-your-billing-practices-affect-malpractice-verdicts", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://blog.curi.com/hubfs/Curi-logo-horizontal-positive-2.png" }, "name" : "Curi - Raleigh, NC" } } ```